Your experience is your advantage with AI

There is a quiet worry I hear from nonprofit leaders, especially those of us who have been doing this a while. "AI is for the younger, tech-savvy folks. I'm already behind." Others feel they are already at capacity, with no time to learn something new.

I understand both feelings. But a small investment of time up front pays off the very first time you use it, and it keeps paying off, day after day. And the experience you already have is what makes it work.

AI is very good at producing a first draft. It is not good at knowing whether that draft is right. That takes judgment: knowing your donors, your board, your members, your community, and what a strong grant narrative actually sounds like. That judgment is exactly what years of doing the work give you.

Think of AI as a bright new hire

Picture a new staff member on their first day. Fast. Well read. Eager. And knows nothing about your organization, your people, or how you like things done.

That is AI. Give it a vague request and you get a generic answer. Give it the background, examples of what good looks like, and a clear sense of who will read it, and it does excellent work.

Who knows how to brief a new hire? Someone who has managed people. Who knows what a funder wants to read? Someone who has written dozens of proposals. Your experience is the briefing.

Three ways experience shows up in better results

1. You know what to ask for. A beginner types "write a donor thank-you letter." An experienced leader writes: "Write a thank-you to a first-time donor who gave $250 to our summer program. Mention what the gift paid for, keep it under 150 words, sound warm but not gushing, and don't ask for another gift." Same tool. Very different letter.

2. You can spot what is wrong. AI can sound confident and still be wrong: a made-up number, a promise your program can't keep, a phrase a funder would frown at. Experienced eyes catch those in seconds. A newer staff member might not.

3. You have the examples. Your best past letters, reports, and proposals are the most valuable thing you can give an AI tool. Share two or three, and the drafts start to sound like your organization instead of like everyone else.

What this looks like in practice

At the nonprofit I lead, the biggest time savings came on the work I know inside and out. A large grant proposal went from about 30 hours to about 4. Board notes went from an hour to about 15 minutes.

That did not happen because AI knows grants. It happened because I know what a strong proposal needs, could tell the tool exactly that, and could fix what it got wrong. AI did the typing. Experience did the thinking.

Getting started without becoming a tech person

  1. Pick one task you have done a hundred times.

  2. Write down what "good" looks like for it, the way you would explain it to a new staff member.

  3. Find two or three of your best past examples. Remove names, contact details, and anything confidential first, and follow your AI policy.

  4. Ask your AI tool for a draft, giving it your description and your examples.

  5. Edit the draft the way you would edit a staff member's work. Then tell the tool what you changed and why.

  6. Save your instructions so you, and your team, can use them again next time.

The leaders who will get the most from AI are not the ones who know the most about technology. They are the ones who know the most about their work. If that is you, you are not behind. You are ahead.

About this series

This is the first article in my series, Practical AI for Nonprofit Leaders: plain-language guidance for executive directors and staff at small nonprofits and associations. If you are just getting started, begin with the rules. My free AI Use Policy Starter Template will help. And if you would like help setting AI up for your whole team, that is what my Nonprofit AI Setup is for.

Quick answers

Do I need technical skills to use AI well?

No. If you can explain a task to a new employee, you can explain it to an AI tool.

Which tool should I start with?

In my experience, Claude and ChatGPT both work well for nonprofit writing. Pick the one your organization approves, and use an organization account, not a personal one. Then stick with the tool you choose. Learn it well and build your workflows there. Switching back and forth slows you down.

Is it safe to use our past documents?

Remove names, contact information, and anything confidential first, and follow your organization's AI policy. When in doubt, leave it out.

Previous
Previous

Almost every nonprofit uses AI now. Why do so few see results?